FAT WITCH BAKERY

>> 7/4/10

Chelsea Market
75 Ninth Avenue
New York, NY 10011
(888) 41-WITCH


Smack on the border between Chelsea and the Meatpacking District is the Chelsea Market. Goodbye sketchiness, hello boutiques. Goodbye smack-craving tranny hookers on a corner, hello eye-candy escorts at the Gansevoort. Goodbye industrial slaughterhouse, hello restaurant. Goodbye blue collar workers, hello tourists. In keeping with the food theme that the area has become a home to, Chelsea Market has emerged to be essentially a mall for eating things (mostly). From fruit to bread to fish to restaurants that sell dresses to gelato (my next post), Chelsea Market is one big, mostly overpriced gastronomic hub. Among these is the Fat Witch Bakery, a brownie-centric chocolate-lover's paradise.




Fat Witch bakes all of its goodies on the premises, so you can rest assured that they're fresh. None of that Entenmann's stuff that could be a week old by the time you pick it up at the supermarket. Fat Witch's specialty brownies aside, they have about ten standards. I bought six to try. Some were good, but others were less than impressive.



Fat Witch: Dark and moist and heavy on the fudge. A little too dry to be great, but nonetheless a well-above average brownie.

Blonde Witch: This is basically a very thick chocolate chip cookie. It was dryer than it should be and sort of tasteless. If you really want something chocolate chip, go with a standard cookie.
Caramel Witch: This is like the Fat Witch, but with a thin layer of gooey caramel inside it. You almost don't notice it unless you're looking for it. It's not bad, but I preferred the plain one.
Red Witch: The cherry-flavored brownie is only subtly cherried. Once or twice you'll get a burst of cherry flavor, which is nice, but between those two bursts it's just a normal brownie.
Java Witch: If I wasn't told by the wrapper that this was a coffee-flavored brownie, I wouldn't have known. Still this is their best one. It was the most moist and the most rich. The coffee didn't replace the chocolate, so much as enhance it. If you can only get one Fat Witch brownie, get this one.
Breakfast Witch: Yecch. Awful. Gritty and mealy and dry. It's supposed to be like an oatmeal brownie. I like oatmeal and oatmeal raisin cookies, but this one just isn't the same or worth the money.





Brownies average $3 each.


Fat Witch Bakery on Urbanspoon

3 comments:

Wayno2424 July 6, 2010 at 10:04 AM  

Lay off Entemann's, my childhood was filled with those delicious crumb cakes.

Stacey,  July 14, 2010 at 7:22 PM  

The best part about Fat Witch is the $1.50 unwrapped brownies in the afternoons-evenings. And the raspberry-white chocolate ones aren't too dry, thanks to the jam inside.

Caroline August 7, 2010 at 6:11 PM  

I don't know why everyone thinks Fat Witch is so great. They're mostly dry and they don't have that "brownie thing" that makes you crazy wanting a brownie.

You might want to try Mari's Brownies in the Limelight Marketplace. They're really chocolatey and moist. The flavors are cool, like Thai Coffee, Caramel Sea Salt, and (my favorite)Coconut, in addition to kickass Classic and Classic with Walnuts.

If you're craving a brownie, Mari's will totally scratch that itch.

Post a Comment

Copyright Notice

The contents of this website/weblog are the property of its author and are protected under the copyright and intellectual property laws of the United States of America. The views expressed within are the opinions of the author. All rights reserved.

Readers are free to copy and distribute the material contained within, but such external use of the author's original material must be properly attributed to the author. Attribution may be through a link to the author's original work. Derivative use is prohibited. The borrower may not alter, transform, or build upon the work borrowed.

The author is free to change the terms of this copyright at any time and without notice. At the written request by the borrower, the author may choose to waive these rights.

eateryMOBILE

eateryCLOUD

$ $$ $$$ $$$$ $$$$$ 24 Hours Alphabet City American Asian Fusion Astoria Atlas Park Austrian Bagels Bakery Bar Scene Barbecue Baychester Bayside Beer Garden/Hall Belgian Belly Dancing Beyond NY Bistro Boerum Hill Brewery British Bronx Brooklyn Brunch Burgers BYOB Cafe Cajun/Creole Carroll Gardens Cash Only Celebrity Chef Chain Chelsea Chinatown Chinese CLOSED Cobble Hill Cocktails Coffee College Point Comfort Food Deli Dessert Diner Ditmas Park Downtown Dumbo East 40s East 50s East Village Eastern European Elmhurst Events Filipino Financial District Flatiron Flushing Fondue Forest Hills Fort Greene Fort Tryon Park French Gastropub German Glendale Gramercy Grand Central Terminal Greek Greenpoint Greenwich Village Harlem Hell's Kitchen Hoboken Hookah Bar HOT DOGS Howard Beach Indian Irish Pub It begins... Italian Jackson Heights Japanese Korean Koreatown Kosher Latin Lenox Hill Lincoln Center LISTINGS Little Italy Long Island City Lounge Lower East Side Lunch Manhattan Meatpacking District Mediterranean Mexican Michelin Starred Middle Eastern Middle Village Midtown Moroccan Murray Hill Nepali New Zealand NoHo Nolita Noodles Norweigian NY Area NYC Institution Organic Other Outdoor Seating Park Slope Peruvian Pizza Polish Queens Ramen Raw Bar Red Hook Rego Park Rooftop Russian Seafood Small Plates SoHo South African South Street Seaport Southern Spanish Sri Lankan Staten Island Steakhouse Sunnyside Sunset Park Swedish Tapas Tea Thai Trendy TriBeCa Truck Ukrainian Union Square UPDATED Upper East Side Upper West Side Vegetarian Vietnamese Views Vineyard Washington Heights West 30s West 40s West 50s West Village Williamsburg Wine Bar Winery Yemeni

  © Blogger template Simple n' Sweet by Ourblogtemplates.com 2009. Sponsored by: Website Templates | Premium Themes. Distributed by: blog template

Back to TOP